Jay Henry’s

About

Barbeque, Burgers

  • star
    Yelp rating
    3 stars

Location

Adress: 2005 N 1st St, McAlester, OK 74501

Phone: (918) 424-9006

Reviews

  • Adam P.

    star star star star star_border 9 September 2026

    The food is very good (at least the burgers and specialty sandwiches, haven't tried everything else) and the prices are great for the portions you get and the flavor. The staff is always very friendly. It's a tough one to judge though. You've got to hit it either in the fall or spring. It's WAY too hot in the summer, they have no indoor seating. It's almost like an old fashioned food truck, but they do have a shaded patio area. It's really too bad they don't have climate controlled indoor seating. If you can make it home with the food while it's hot or hit it when the weather is cool, it's amazing. If you can't, it's tough to recommend because no one likes cold food or their buns to have soaked up all the grease before they can eat, and no one likes to sweat like a sauna as they eat.

  • Troy B.

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 4 September 2026

    Passing through I had the brisket and hot links. Literally the worst meat I have ever tried, absolutely disgusting, In no was this brisket nor was it smoked, no flavor and most likely boiled. Not often I can't eat something but this was the exception, of course hair on the plate didn't help , I literally threw it all away.

  • Gregg F.

    star star star star star 31 August 2026

    Yeah, great food reasonable prices.  

    I had a big double burger with everything.   My sister had a large BBQ Pork.   Both were quite good. As were the fries and onion rings.  

    Didn't have anything to drink, (Went to Braum's for Chocolate Malts).

    Large selection of sandwiches, some very big.   (Can be shared by two for a single meal.)

    And yes, they take credit cards so feel free to spend.

  • Ron C.

    star star star star star 27 August 2026

    Not a sit down place, but fantastic food.  They'll make anything you ask for.  BBQ meats, etc. on your burger.  Made to order.  The menu is merely a starting point.

  • Sarah S.

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 24 August 2026

    WAY to expensive!  I can make it at home way cheaper and it would have more flavor. Just really plain Jane food at Jay Henry's.

People Recommend